Pm'd on the sourcing. Local shop I go to most is Ziggaren.
Try a variety, from mild to full, and sweet to spice. Your opinions will change based on the last meal you had an the pairings you are enjoying the cigar with.
My top 5 are mostly full flavour. Not really first time smoker cigars, but some I can't get enough of.
1) Liga Privada #9 Robusto
2) Tatuaje Fausto Esteli 144
3) Cohiba Secretos Maduro
4) Liga Privada T52 Robusto
5) Romeo Y Julieta Short Churchill
Special mentions go out to:
6) Room 101 OSOK
7) Trinidad Reyes
Punch Royal Selection #12 (I have one that is 13 years old, and I can't wait for the right occasion to smoke it)