I was helping a friend buy a Knolly Endorphin last night (also sold a $400 helmet for the shop I was in
) and I was able to test ride a 2010 Trek Remedy 8 in my size (XL).
I've been toying with the idea of getting a Remedy, Endorphin, Butcher or light build Nomad as a trail bike and throwing a 180mm fork on my Delirium T.
Starting from the back of the list.
Butcher - I can see why its cheaper. It weighs a fair bit for what it is and it can't pedal as well as a VPP bike.
Nomad - This isn't too terribly different from my DT. Sure, it climbs well but it really is a "one bike" type bike.
Endorphin - Can't find an XL to ride and this is really a FR bike in AM clothing
Trek - Seems like a good AM bike and for now the way to go
*sigh*