It's fine. The co-driver call outs can be off course inducing inconsistent which is frustrating.
Some cars and surfaces feel really good and relatively accurate, and some do not.
I think it has a varied enough car list, and for the most part the stages are fun. The stages tend to look similar to one another, but you don't notice too much since you're driving through them.
I've seen some of the damage modelling be kind of inconsistent, a small off ending someone's rally while a large crash was just a reset and let them keep going.
The UI is bad and the features are sparse. They just released a big (18GB) patch that may address some of the UI issues.