I had a better look at the glass last night and things lined up quite nicely (almost as if the glass was OEM
). I am still puzzled as to what my first glass shop was telling me. Curves all seem the exact same on both pieces of glass.
Glass was now just dropped off with a second shop. Install to come later this morning. We will see if the glass goes on or not. Will update later this afternoon! Doesn't seem like there's much information on this topic, so it looks like i'm the guinea pig in this sense.