Just quoting what Subaru techs at Rally Suby in Edmonton passed along to me... for these old JDM's everyone should be sticking religiously to the 94 juice unless a tuning solution is installed on the car, and even if that's done, avoid Shell.
Per said techs, Shell should be avoided as it has the most history of poor quality control, and the highest number of engine failures directly related to the quality of fuel being used.
Stick to the Husky/Mohawk fellers, and invest in a tuning solution, Speed Stick and I can both vouch for the gains you get out of it.